Schedule a Consultation | Toll Free: 1-800-678-1307
Trial lawyers specializing in personal injury and civil litigation

Michigan Supreme Court to reconsider Kreiner no fault "serious impairment" standard?

The Associated Press reported on August 21 that the Michigan Supreme Court has agreed to reconsider a case involving the "life-altering" serious impairment interpretation of the no fault law adopted by Justice Clifford Taylor and the so-called Engler Gang of Four.  The latter justices, hand-selected by then-Governor Engler with an eye toward cozying up to the Chamber of Commerce and the insurance industry, adopted a number of lawsuit "reforms," including a re-analysis of the no fault threshold that severely limited when injured car accident victims could sue. 

Under Taylor's analysis, a 4-3 majority of the Court re-wrote the legislative "serious impairment" threshold by requiring that injuries be not only an "objectively manifested serious impairment of bodily function" but also requiring that they have a "life-altering" impact on the victim.  Rodney McCormick was one of the last victims denied a right to sue (on a 4-3 vote) before Taylor left the Supreme Court bench in 2008.  He could not sue even though he suffered a broken ankle requiring two separate surgeries and keeping him out of work for more than a year.  When he returned to work, it was with different job duties because his employer did not think he could handle his old job functions, and he has on-going pain and joint degeneration in the affected ankle.

The Supreme Court voted 4-3 last week to give McCormick's case a second hearing--indicating a likelihood that the new Court majority will reconsider the Taylor court's activist re-writing of the legislative "objectively manifested serious impairment of a bodily function" standard.  By the normal operation of the Court, the case is likely to be heard during the early winter of 2009-2010.

Thompson O’Neil, P.C.
309 East Front Street
Traverse City, Michigan 49684
Toll Free: 1-800-678-1307
Fax: 231-929-7262